Manhattan Strip Clubs: Victory Mosque Removal
Instead, I urge you to consider turning the site into a center for interfaith encounter. Build the mosque—but do so together with a church and a synagogue and a center for common reflection for all three faiths and for those with no faith. Do this, Imam Feisal, not to surrender to your critics but to honor their pain, and, in the process, to honor Islam.
In the abstract, such a center would be a wonderful idea. Is it “better” (from the standpoint of interfaith healing? From the a general social utility view?) than the current blueprints? It’s hard to say, though I suspect that, under whatever standard that labels such a center superior to Park 51, that same center would be a “better” usage for nearly any parcel of land publicly or privately developed in New York City (those strip clubs spring immediately to mind). And I maintain that, if the purpose of the community center is to serve the Muslim community in Southern Manhattan, it kind of misses the point to relocate the center to